Last week I posted that there seems to be a bit of an Elric / Moorcock revival going on, based on the proliferation of Elric or pro-Moorcock content on YouTube..
Then the RPG world exploded with TWO big announcements.
TWO HARBINGERS
First, Free League announced an Elric RPG based on Dragonsbane.
Then, Goodman games of Dungeon Crawl Classics announced THEIR Elric game.
What do I make of these announcements?
Nobody asked for it, but here are my two Large Bronzes.
THE ONE I AM BUYING
I don't think it is any surprise but I will be ordering Free League's game. Dragonbane from what I have read is a spiritual successor to the old Chaosium games, and from what I know probably fits between the original Stormbringer and the fanmade Barbarians of Lemur hack floating around on the inter webs in terms of mechanics.
Content wise, if Free League can do LotR right, I'm interested to see what they'll do with the Young Kingdoms.
As for DCC/5E, I am largely over the OSR and vanilla fantasy. I am also moving past my distaste of 5E - I appreciate that people play it for relaxation, don't really use the rules, and make meme characters for laughs. Good on them, and a good antidote to the tiring corporate touting of D&D as "world's greatest" and the glut of 5E products.
I am a proud member of the I'm Begging You To Play Another RPG FB page, where we regularly promote indie and lesser known TRPGs and bag on 5E / WotC marketing bloat. But I also feel that people should play what they want (while hopefully trying new things), and Goodman Games are experts in both marketing and getting people to the table.
So I wish them well, and would sit in on a game in a heartbeat.
WHICH ONE SHOULD YOU GET?
If you got the cash, why not get both? The older editions have doubled or trebled in price the past few years, so this may be the only way to get an affordable official Elric game.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
I'll go out on a limb and say that with this much buzz, an Elric TV show or movie is nigh inevitable. If the suits catch on that The Witcher is an Elric pastiche, they might bankroll the project. However, their interference might also make it go pear shaped.
In my dream dimension, Ralph Bakshi has come out of retirement to make it. Dude made Fire and Ice and Wizards, the Secret of Nimh. He can do no wrong in my book.
Exciting (and unsettling) days ahead for us Moorcock lovers! I hope that Michael is getting a well deserved cut of the proceeds.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your assessment of Bakshi. Live-action would be pretty nifty, though.
I’d stay live action if they can use older cameras and not this flat digital bullshit. I’m gonna go out on a limb here and say I’d rather see a Japanese or Chinese filmmaker do it and add an alien flair then a Hollywood version
DeleteThere's already so many trappings of "Orientalism" in Melnibonean design, though...I don't know, man.
Delete[still, I'd take anything. Except maybe a Bali-wood Elric]
Is anyone still doing stop-motion stuff?
If I recall correctly, Elric is first described wearing a yellow silk kimono. So even Mike was in on the Oriental habidashery. Stop motion or a good anime might be the ticket. I thought the French comics of a few years back were a little bit too grim dark for me. My favourite depiction thus far is Roy Thomas and Craig Russell‘s 90s and 80s comics. They really captured the psychedelia of the source.
DeleteHaving red Elrick in Japanese and being a scholar of Japanese society, I think the cruelty edge was very well done in the Japanese edition, as was the social hierarchy of Melnibone Can we
DeleteI own all the Thomas/Russell comics in collected (hardcover) form...seven volumes. The early ones (circa '89-'90) were VERY influential for me and probably (if I recall) my introduction to stories. They're (still) quite delightful.
ReplyDelete